Answer Thread

[Izumiko (Emi)]

Questions for all Deaths

1. How many culprits are related to the deaths at hand? Which deaths are these people connected to and how?

2. What is ultimately the cause of death for each victim? If a weapon or tool was involved, what was it? (Example: Knife stabbed Ven’s heart </3)

3. In which order did the victims die? When did their deaths happen?

4. In which room/area did each victim die?

5. How many fires were started this night and how were they all started? Were any of them related to the case at hand? When did the fire start?

6. Identify all the red herrings of this trial.

7. What evidence was destroyed this night? How was it destroyed?

8. Were any abilities used by the culprit(s)? Attempt to discern how (Bonus).


Pup Related Questions:

9. How was Pup attacked? Describe the process of the murder.

10. Why did Pup's body 'appear' out of thin air?

11. What is the purpose of the barrel?

12. What is an important piece of evidence found in the Vestibule? Where did it come from? How was it used? What happened to it?

13. If this is a locked room murder, how did the killer escape the room?


Contract Specific Questions:

14. How was Contract attacked? Describe the process of the murder.

15. What items/materials were involved in this murder? Where did they come from?

16. If this is a locked room murder, how did the killer escape the room?


Master Onion Specific Questions:

17. How was Master Onion attacked? Describe the process of the murder.

18. What items/materials were involved in this murder? Where did they come from?

19. Who delivered this killing blow? Why?

20. Who was supposed to be the original victim? What happened for the circumstances to change?

[Kuroneko]

These seem to be answers that won't really change much, but feel free to split this up if you dont agree with anything.

2. What is ultimately the cause of death for each victim? If a weapon or tool was involved, what was it? (Example: Knife stabbed Ven’s heart </3)
With the lack of blood spray from the stab, Pup was likely strangled to death. Contract died to fire started by something like a molotov. Onion died to a crossbow bolt in the chest.

3. In which order did the victims die? When did their deaths happen?
Contract and Pup died A4. Pup left the room immediately and met his demise as after entering the ballroom, so he was the first death. Contract was delayed by everyone bumping into each other, so it took him longer to get to the guesthouse. Contract Onion died A6.

4. In which room/area did each victim die?
Pup died in the ballroom. Contract died in the guesthouse. Onion died in the grand hall.

5. How many fires were started this night and how were they all started? Were any of them related to the case at hand? When did the fire start?
Tamaki started three fires, with five total among the playerbase. One to ignite the whip at the furnace A4, the second with the paints in the drawing room A5, and the third by spreading flaming paint around while dancing in the grand hall A6. Brickster started one by burning the pasta and throwing it into the pantry A5. Satorae started the last by burning down the guesthouse during A4. The guesthouse fire was the only one realted to the case.

13. If this is a locked room murder, how did the killer escape the room?
The killer escaped out the window.

19. Who delivered this killing blow? Why?
Egret was coerced into shooting someone. Egret found a threatening note and was instructed that they must shoot someone within 5 seconds or become the victim.

[Kuroneko]

1. How many culprits are related to the deaths at hand? Which deaths are these people connected to and how?
Considering the overlap in materials, there were two culprits. Satorae bbq Contract while Onion strangled Pup and then committed upsidedown sudoku took an arrow to the knee chest.

[Kuroneko]

1. How many culprits are related to the deaths at hand? Which deaths are these people connected to and how?
There were two culprits and an accomplice. Satorae murderer Contract. Onion and Maison were accomplices for the deaths of Pup and Onion. The knife is a lie intended to sow confusion.

[Kuroneko]

1. How many culprits are related to the deaths at hand? Which deaths are these people connected to and how?
There were two culprits and an accomplice. Satorae murderer Contract. Onion and Sonia were accomplices for the deaths of Pup and Onion.

[Kuroneko]

6. Identify all the red herrings of this trial.
The spear wound on Pup is a red herring to draw attention from the fishing lines. The almond milk is there to make it seem like Contract was poisoned with cyanide.

[Kuroneko]

7. What evidence was destroyed this night? How was it destroyed?
Rope and climbing gear was used to get on the guesthouse roof, which was then discarded in the fireplace with the rest of the flammables. This accounts for the metal item and possibly a material. The plastic and glass were something along the lines of a molotov and lighter. The last material item is likely a wooden weapon like an axe from the shed.

[Kuroneko]

8. Were any abilities used by the culprit(s)? Attempt to discern how.
Onion or his accomplice had the ability to sneak around without anyone noticing, thus explaining how they placed the note before Maison and held a knife to his throat without being noticed.

[Kuroneko]

10. Why did Pup's body 'appear' out of thin air?
Pup was carried to the vestibule by sneaking around the main gardens and courtyard, as Sonia was watching the hallway. The explosive locked room was set up and they sneaked back into the ballroom along the same path.

[Kuroneko]

11. What is the purpose of the barrel?
The barrel blocks the door to the main hall creating the illusion of a locked room.

[Kuroneko]

12. What is an important piece of evidence found in the Vestibule? Where did it come from? How was it used? What happened to it?
The spears are important as reveal where Pup died and the amount of blood indicates that he had been strangled to death. It came from the ballroom and was used to stab Pup post mortem. The spear was left in the vestibule as a red herring.

[Kuroneko]

14. How was Contract attacked? Describe the process of the murder.
Contract was knocked unconscious with a blow to the head. The culprit escaped out the chimney and dropped all their tools down said chimney to start the fire and get rid of evidence. Contract died in the fire.

[Kuroneko]

14. How was Contract attacked? Describe the process of the murder.
Contract was killed with a blow to the head. The culprit escaped out the chimney and dropped all their tools down said chimney to start the fire and get rid of evidence. The fire was simply there to make it hard to get to the scene.

[Kuroneko]

16. If this is a locked room murder, how did the killer escape the room?
The killer escaped up the chimney with climbing equipment.

[Kuroneko]

16. If this is a locked room murder, how did the killer escape the room?
The killer escaped out a window in a similar fashion to the vestibule.