Trial 2

[superweegee]

Mar 19, 2017 17:23:22 GMT -6 Alucard said:

"I believe it is Aqua then! Why? Because it all adds up! Unless John Doe is lying."

Aqua's movements:
Media Room>Dorm Room>Pool Supply Room>Lost Track>Library

Rinako said:

"Lucifen immediately went to the Media Room. It very much seems like the video had her in shock and awe - she doesn't seem to have left the room for a long while. When she eventually left, the steps she took seem unaware, in that she may have been mentally hyper focused on one thing, but also very precise, in that she was very assuredly going someplace with a specific purpose."

-So By ...sheer coincidence... the victim and Aqua met in the media room. It is also true that apparently something happened in there that caused Lucifen to be in shock and go somewhere. She did this after a while, meaning that by the time she did, Aqua could have been waiting in the pool supply room! We know he visited the room. Before going there he visited his dorm. Why? Because he needed a weapon is what I think! Not to mention Aqua's character looks hella female! (Those nails yo). He has a sharp proficiency too! Of course he was in the library too.


So here's what I think: Aqua met Lucifen in the media room, and made her go to the pool. He grabbed a weapon in his dorm, and walked to the pool supply room. There he attacked her. (granted she walked to the female changing room and aqua apparently walked to the supply room first but she got turned around so he probably made a noise from behind her or something) After attacking her, he blocked the female changing room and used a male student card to get back to the other side. He hid the card in the library. 

But alu he never visited the bookshelf

Projectile proficiency.

And how coincidental that John Doe lost track of Aqua after she left the Pool Supply room.

[Monotaro]

Mar 19, 2017 17:23:22 GMT -6 Alucard said:

But alu he never visited the bookshelf

Projectile proficiency.

Tsurugi walks over to Alucard's podium and flips it over.

"YOU THINK YOU CAN JUST SAY PROJECTILE AND THE CONTRADICTION MAGICALLY GOES AWAY?! I had eyes like a hawk on that bookshelf, I tell you! And while the footage was a bit grainy, I think I'd notice something go flying into the bookshelves! Also, why are some of you still suspecting Satori? I thought her innocence last trial was all but proven..."

[Alucard]

Mar 19, 2017 18:01:23 GMT -6 Monotaro said:

Mar 19, 2017 17:23:22 GMT -6 Alucard said:

But alu he never visited the bookshelf

Projectile proficiency.

Tsurugi walks over to Alucard's podium and flips it over.

"YOU THINK YOU CAN JUST SAY PROJECTILE AND THE CONTRADICTION MAGICALLY GOES AWAY?! I had eyes like a hawk on that bookshelf, I tell you! And while the footage was a bit grainy, I think I'd notice something go flying into the bookshelves!"

As it turns out Aqua's character is actually male. I would have found a reason for you not noticing it but I can't change Aqua's gender so there goes that accusation.

[superweegee]

Mar 19, 2017 18:04:07 GMT -6 Alucard said:

Mar 19, 2017 18:01:23 GMT -6 Monotaro said:

Tsurugi walks over to Alucard's podium and flips it over.

"YOU THINK YOU CAN JUST SAY PROJECTILE AND THE CONTRADICTION MAGICALLY GOES AWAY?! I had eyes like a hawk on that bookshelf, I tell you! And while the footage was a bit grainy, I think I'd notice something go flying into the bookshelves!"

As it turns out Aqua's character is actually male. I would have found a reason for you not noticing it but I can't change Aqua's gender so there goes that accusation.

Just because someone blocked the female bathroom doesn't necessarily mean that the killer is female.

For all we know, he could've blocked the door to prevent the victim from escaping or something.

[Sycihu Savage]

Mar 19, 2017 18:04:07 GMT -6 Alucard said:

As it turns out Aqua's character is actually male. I would have found a reason for you not noticing it but I can't change Aqua's gender so there goes that accusation.

"Oh good. Looks like I don't have to point out the obvious flaws."

"Also, I think it was mentioned that the inside of the female changing room was clean... I'd think there would have been some signs if it had happened there. Unfortunately, this also means that a certain someone else might have blocked the entrance to the female changing room..."

"But I'd not like to think of that possibility."

[Lee Yuha [Hansel]]

Heeding the results of her comrades, Mina finds the whole thing insufficient to unravel this enigma without her own findings. She leans her head and chest forward, sticking out of her podium.


"Hey, hey. Is it my time to speak now? Got some juicy deets here."





"Before anything else, I'd like everyone to know that I've investigated both the changing rooms together with Miyoshi but I lingered for a longer while to extract most information out of it, since, after all, the rooms are significantly relevant to solving this case, and might help us narrow down our list of suspects by ascertaining the sex of our culprit.


"I'd like to start by disseminating the info I obtained from merely inspecting the two rooms. I've found the same thing as Miyoshi, but I can tell more supplementary details. In the Male Changing Room, one of the lockers seems to have been used more recently than the others. There were also a few drops of water on the ground of it. In the Female Changing Room, what serves as the obstruction behind its door was one of the benches inside the room.


"Now, I can't just walk away just with this superficial info on my hands. So I probed the premise further.


"I really wanted to find out what the sex of the blackened is and to accomplish that I attempted to find out what could be the things that my eyes missed. Upon further scrutiny, I discovered the following.


1. The used locker in the male changing room was slightly open when I entered.


2. The droplets appear to puddle around this specific locker.


3. There were almost indiscernible wet footprints from pool door to this locker in question.


4. I opened the locker to see what were inside. The locker is equipped with an automatic hot-air blower, and a single, dry school bathing suit which was briefs.


5. All the doors were closed. What's curious though is the doorknob of the pool—>male changing room is slightly wet.


6. By contrast, I found no traces of water anywhere in the female changing room.


6. The bench obstructing the door is not damp on any of its part.


"Moreover, I asked Sho about the school policy regarding a student's access to gender-specific rooms. Minanomoto said,'In this Game, all gender-specific rooms can be entered by anyone at any time. All of these doors, however, remain locked until opened with a respective student handbook.' So I could easily enter the male changing room with the use of any male handbook. ((Codeskull , I wonder if this is also the case in the baths or washrooms?))


"Now, whose ID was stolen again? Allen's? I don't know who they are, really, but from what I've heard they're male, right?


"Anyway, let's proceed to my theory!

---

MINA MYOUI'S THEORY




"Let's consider for now that anyone could've done this.


If our culprit were a male, this is what he would've done:


1. He would need to steal a female handbook.
2. The blocking of the door could be done in two ways but he would have to do this before he gets soaked in water since there are no traces of water in the FCR. They could either:

a. With the use of the female handbook, enter the FCR, block the door with the bench and exit.
b. Enter through MCR using their own handbook, proceed to FCR with the stolen female handbook, and block the door.
((I know there really isn't a difference but bear with me.))

3. Proceed with their plan in the Pool Room. He gets wet.
4. The only exit he could take is through the MCR. This is where he would dry himself and possibly change outfit.


If our culprit were a female, these are the actions she would have to do:


1. Steal a male handbook. (A male handbook was discovered in the library.)
2. Enter through FCR, block the door, and proceed to Pool Room. After this, she can't access FCR any more, otherwise there would be wet footprints in the FCR.
3. Proceed with their plan in the Pool Room. She gets wet.
4. Again, the only exit she could take is through the MCR. She would use the male handbook to enter. This is where she dries herself up.


"Either way, any student of both sexes would have to steal the other's handbook since both the rooms were conspicuously involved here. I know females are most likely the suspects now because of the male handbook found in the library. But why would she leave the male handbook when this would give her away, when this would result in our discovery that they needed a male handbook?


"What if the murderer were a male and stole two handbooks, i.e. that of Allen and of a female, most likely of the victim of the previous trial or the current victim? They used the stolen male handbook to throw us off. To mislead us.


"Plus it wouldn't make sense to kill two females when this could be a disadvantage to her!"



"'Kay, I'm done. I'll give your findings and speculations a listen. But there's a guy here who seems to be very suspicious to me. Hmm..."

[Sycihu Savage]

"The killer had a female's handbook."

"Specifically, they'd theoretically have had access to the handbook of Riliane herself when both her and the killer were in the pool area. Perhaps some of you may remember that the eHandbooks are either waterproof or water-resistant, but I do believe they are waterproof. Meaning the killer could have easily stolen Riliane's handbook from her body, then blocked the door that way."

"Finally, the blood was found on the outside handle of the door. However, I do not believe the handle on the inside was found as bloody either. If the killer bloodied the handle after the murder, which we can probably assume did happen, then I doubt it was before the room was blocked. After all, if it were, then it would make sense that the killer would have left traces of blood on the inside as well."

"That said, I think we can assume that the blood on the handle of the female changing room is a red herring set by the killer to throw us off. Add this onto what we already know..."

"And Aqua has a lot of explaining to do, doesn't he? After all, he also very forcefully created the bandwagon on Kenzaki in the last game with little to no solid evidence, didn't he?"

[Lee Yuha [Hansel]]

Mar 19, 2017 18:42:43 GMT -6 Sycihu Savage said:

"Finally, the blood was found on the outside handle of the door. However, I do not believe the handle on the inside was found as bloody either. If the killer bloodied the handle after the murder, which we can probably assume did happen, then I doubt it was before the room was blocked. After all, if it were, then it would make sense that the killer would have left traces of blood on the inside as well."

"Blood on the outside handle of the door? Well, uh, Mr. Masked Man, what door particularly are you hinting at? I found blood traces on neither changing room. Are you mistaking my results with Tetsu?"

[Tetsu]

You're mistaken man, I checked the bath area outside of the pool area~ so if it's indeed a red herring~ where did the blood come from? Cause as I recall the anotomist said the Evil Princess was strangled unconscious and both the Modus Operandi is kinda similar from the first trial and the second one. Right?" Tetsu then said

[Homin Muz]

So you want me to explain why i visited certain places?

Um... how the heck am I supposed to defend myself here?

We all have amnesia here...

All I have to say is that John Doe has, for the past two trials now, investigated people who seem to fit the killer's movements perfectly.

Just sayin, don't know if he's lying or what but I can't exactly say that I never visited those places...

[superweegee]

Mar 19, 2017 19:06:06 GMT -6 Homin Muz said:

So you want me to explain why i visited certain places?

Um... how the heck am I supposed to defend myself here?

We all have amnesia here...

All I have to say is that John Doe has, for the past two trials now, investigated people who seem to fit the killer's movements perfectly.

Just sayin, don't know if he's lying or what but I can't exactly say that I never visited those places...

So you admit that you went to those places, then?

[Homin Muz]

Ok weegee let me put this into context.

What is your alibi last night? What were your actions? Or are those thinggs that you can only get from looking at evidence that was found during investigation?

As it stands now, I can't tell you my alibi, because I haven't looked at what other people have posted.

So yeah.

[Codeskull]

Mar 19, 2017 18:25:59 GMT -6 Lee Yuha [Hansel] said:

((Codeskull , I wonder if this is also the case in the baths or washrooms?))

A+, pop girl. All gender specific rooms, which includes bathrooms, function this way. Such is the function of the school's composer creator.

[Lee Yuha [Hansel]]

"Well, if that's the case, there's only one place I could think where the blood might have come from. The Infirmary. I wish someone had checked the place. But whatever. 

"You found nothing else inside either washroom, right, Tetsu ? I think the culprit here is really a male trying to frame the females, most likely to still draw suspicion to Satori. First, the blocked door from the inside of the Female Changing Room. Second, a stolen male handbook discovered in the Library. Now, a crusty blood on the Female Washroom? Why would a female do all these? Unless of course they're cunning.

"So far, I will be basing my suspect list on Tsurugi's result, specifically on the tape showing those who have acquired books from the bookshelves."

---

• Chiyoko - grabbed a book twice; female; S/B || +2 Suspicious Points
• Savage - grabbed a book twice; male; S/P || +3 Suspicious Points
• Silent - grabbed a book twice; male; S/B || +3 Suspicious Points
• Kaname - grabbed a book twice; male; S/P || +3 Suspicious Points
• Miyoshi - once; female; S/P || +1 Suspicious Point
• Cathell - once; male; S/P || +2 Suspicious Point
• Satori - once; female; B/P || Not Suspicious At All Leave Her Alone Point
• Rinako - grabbed a book twice; female; S/P || +2 Suspicious Points
• Tamotsu - once; ((i can't determine his info on the spreadsheet)) S/B || +1 Suspicious Point
• Vinny - grabbed a book twice; male; S/P || +3 Suspicious Points
  
  
  Top 4 Suspects:
  
  
  • Savage
  • Silent
  • Kaname
  • Vinny
  
  

"What make me think the blackened is male are the possible red herrings, the victim's a female, and that the locker in the male changing room has been used more than the other lockers in that room, implying that the killer could have visited this many times."

((jeez, i just realized that we haven't established the cause of death yet. y i k e s. or the murder weapon and the killer's method. or the murder location. y i k e s  i n t e n s i f i e s.))

[Homin Muz]

I'm just going to throw this out there (won't type lengthy thing), I personally think it is Vinny.

He tells his brother who to investigate, and who his brother investigated always seems to fit the killer's actions.

Plus with what Hansel said...