Post by Syaoran on May 31, 2014 13:05:18 GMT -6
I have a lot of reading to do TT
Edit: well, I can just as well place my post here as there hasn't been posted after me xD
quite some pages but quite some short posts so it wasn’t that bad xD
Next Syaoran- Toilet... no body can actually support the fact and say that you were indeed in the toilet while the murder occurred. You could easily went in stab lustful and went to the toilet immediately to clean yourself.
(problem here is that we got no idea which toilet you are in)Wouldn't yosuke give a more detailed location rather then toilet?
Flandree, Yeah when I read that I was on the toilet I also didn't know where that would be xd still don’t but I assume it is somewhere in the vicinity of the kitchen as I’m the 2nd to enter when Lustfull is found.
As for the fact that nobody can confirm me at the toilet, can’t help that… Only thing I can say is that before Lustfull was found I am not confirmed at the kitchen am I?
Now the more I have thought about this the more crazy theories I have come up with here is my main one:
Syaoran was heading to the toilet when he had noticed the smell of meat, wondering what it was he started heading towards the kitchen (like many of the other students did and as he was going through the halls he noticed skadoodley go by carrying the fat (similiar to hero skadoodley once again took no notice of syaoran). Syaoran then headed to the kitchen wanting to get a look at the food, that is when he noticed lustful was still in there cooking up the meat, syaoran then made small talk with lustful until he turned his back to grab something or put something on the cabinet (the cabinet his dead body was leaning on) he then fled to the toilet.
Now obviously that incriminates syaoran making him my prime suspect right now.
Also I do have another theory but this is my theory B:
Skadoodley decided to start cooking the meat with lustful knowing he would have a chance at killing him, and so skadoodley was itching to kill him the entire time and so when nazo and Fladree entered (at different times) he just small talked them until they left. He then decides once hey are alone that it is the perfect time to kill and so he asks lustful to grab something from the cabinet for him and then he commited the crime. Then while going to dispose of the fat he was shocked at how easy that kill was and so took no notice of hero while walking past because he was in a world of his own.
Now my theory B has a lot of flaws and so for now I'm going to use the first one. Now if anyone else has anything helpful to say please do.
-1 skadoodley
+syaoran
Akira, I pretty much enjoyed your theories, I personally would’ve switched them around tho. You say that theory B is pretty flawed, since your theory is almost the same as mine I think that one is less flawed.
This is because of the flaws I see in theory A, sure I could’ve went to the toilet and noticed the smell. However, if I would have seen Skadoodley while he was throwing away the fat wouldn’t I have been spotted by either Skadoodley or Hero? The G&R center isn’t that far from the kitchen so even if Skadoodley missed me I think Hero would have seen me.
Now, even if I passed by unnoticed and went to the kitchen I would have needed to talk to Lustfull, this should take some time. Time enough for Skadoodley to return and spot me. Also I most likely would have passed by Nazo since he left pretty close before or Kitana would have seen me.
If we compare that to Skadoodley, he was with Lustfull, had a knife and had a window of opportunity that he could use. After Nazo left he needed to burn the fat, this gave Skadoodley a window to get away from the scene. This would also make him seem innocent as he had a reason to go away.
@ everyone, this 3way tie is unnecessary. I won’t ask you guys to make it into a single person but looking at the evidence and the clean cut I really doubt it is Kitana. Vocalist specialize in blunt objects, I believe she would not be able to make such a clean cut.
For now I will stay by my theory, I haven’t seen anything to completely disprove it yet so yeah~~ I will keep my vote in my pocket for a couple of hours more in the hope Siren posts and she posts some important information.
